Broad Mountain Files Legal Challenge to Packer Township’s Recently Amended Zoning Ordinance for Wind Farm Development

MEDIA CONTACT: Kurt Knaus | kurt@ceislermedia.comC 717.571.5687

WEATHERLY, Carbon County (Aug. 29, 2019) — In its ongoing efforts to construct and operate an environmentally beneficial wind farm, Broad Mountain Power LLC today filed a formal appeal with the Carbon County Court of Common Pleas challenging recent zoning ordinance amendments made by Packer Township that effectively could block the development of future wind projects within the municipality.

The challenge seeks to invalidate the procedurally flawed ordinance amendments because the township did not follow strict statutory requirements as set forth in the state’s Municipalities Planning Code for public notice, public hearings and public comment on the proposed amendments.

The amendments represent substantial changes to the previously existing ordinance that allowed turbines, while at the same time minimizing or mitigating impacts. The amended ordinance essentially makes it impossible to construct or operate a modern wind farm within Packer Township.

“At Broad Mountain Power, we have operated in an open and transparent manner since day one, making sure local elected officials and residents have all the information they need about our proposed project,” Broad Mountain Power Project Manager Rob Miller said.

“We regret that it has come to this and that we have to take this action,” Miller continued. “But this appeal is necessary to protect and promote landowner rights and to allow for the construction and operation of environmentally beneficial, clean wind energy projects in Packer Township and across the nation.”

According to the appeal, some of the defects with the amended zoning ordinance, based on provisions of the Municipalities Planning Code, include:

The township failed to include a statement that copies of the proposed ordinance may be examined without charge or obtained for a charge not greater than the cost thereof in the Notice of Special Meeting.

The township failed to make complete copies of the proposed ordinance amendments available for inspection at the county law library and the Hazleton Standard-Speaker, where notice about the special meeting was advertised.

At least 10 days prior to enactment, the township failed to re-advertise in one newspaper of general circulation in the municipality, a brief summary setting forth all the amendment provisions in reasonable detail, together with a summary of the amendments.

The township failed to provide notice of another “public hearing.”

The township failed to hold a public hearing before proceeding to vote on and enact the proposed amendments.

Projects like Broad Mountain and other wind farm developments are crucial to providing clean energy that helps to power economies while still addressing the harmful effects of climate change. The project is even more crucial for Pennsylvania, which recently set a statewide goal to promote clean energy projects to save taxpayer money and create jobs.

In January, the state put forth a new executive order establishing the first statewide goal to reduce carbon pollution in Pennsylvania, which is contributing to climate change. The state will work to achieve a 26 percent reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by 2025 and an 80 percent reduction by 2050, from 2005 levels. That includes the state itself procuring renewable energy to offset at least 40 percent of the commonwealth’s annual electricity use.

These goals simply cannot be met without projects like Broad Mountain.

Broad Mountain Power plans to construct and operate an 80-megawatt, 21-turbine project in Packer Township. Upon completion, the project will produce enough clean electricity to power about 25,000 homes a year. The project currently is under review by Packer Township’s zoning hearing board.

Broad Mountain Power has a field office at 202 Carbon Street in Weatherly. More information is available toll-free at 1-866-591-5005 or online at www.broadmountainwindproject.com.

View the filing HERE.

###

Wind company launches balloons

Published July 27, 2019 07:33AM

BY JARRAD HEDES JMHEDES@TNONLINE.COM

A balloon test conducted by officials with the Broad Mountain Wind Project went off without a hitch Friday morning after being delayed nearly a week due to high winds.

Workers from Digital Design and Imaging Service Inc. prepare to launch a balloon test to show the height of the proposed wind turbines in Packer Township. CONTRIBUTED PHOTO

Four balloons were elevated within the footprint of the proposed 21-turbine wind farm in Packer Township to serve as a representative example and provide additional data for site analyses to be submitted as part of the ongoing zoning hearing process.

“This was all for visual impact assessment to give people a visual marker of where these turbines would be,” said Rob Miller, project manager. “Earlier, we gave a visual report to the zoning board where we superimposed the turbines, showing where they would be. The board requested this balloon test. It’s not all that common, but we were happy to check off that box.”

A team from Digital Design and Imaging Service Inc. conducted the test, with balloons flying well past the anticipated two hours.

The crew flew three white balloons at the proposed 656-foot tall turbines when the blade tip is at its apex. A smaller orange balloon marked the 418-foot height of the top of the turbine tower.

The four balloons were spread across different parts of the wind farm, with one each on the far eastern and western ends and two others in between along the ridge.

In May, attorney Greg Mousseau, speaking for the Packer zoning hearing board, explained the board is trying to determine a “field of view” for the entire project. They are hoping for a “panoramic view,” versus the simulated photos provided so far, to show “the visual impact to existing homes.”

“The weather was beautiful today and really gave us a chance to give the community that visual they were looking for,” Miller said. “There were photographers out today at around 15-16 different locations, and we’ll be taking those images and giving a new visual impact piece to the board that will include the balloons as well as the previously superimposed turbine images.”

The test was originally slated for last weekend, but Miller said balloon experts advised against the flight due to 15-20-knot winds on the Broad Mountain.

Packer Township’s zoning board had requested 26 balloons to show each pad site, but Miller said that wasn’t practical or safe.

“People were out and about today to see this test and how it would look,” he added. “A neighbor rented a plane to check it out from that perspective.”

Miller said he hopes to bring the images from today before the zoning hearing board during a scheduled Aug. 14 hearing. Before that, a hearing is scheduled for Aug. 7.”

As for whether the public, who had concerns about the visual impact of the proposed turbines, would be swayed by Friday’s event, Miller said beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

“I think some people view turbines as progressive and see the economical and environmental impact, while others just don’t like them,” he said. “I think the visual impact is one of the biggest concerns people have going into this, so hopefully some of those concerns were put to rest.”

UPDATE: Broad Mountain Wind Balloon Test Reset for July 26

Weatherly Plaza • 202 Carbon Street • Weatherly, PA 18255

Phone Toll Free: 1-866-591-5005

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Media Contact: Kurt Knaus, 717-571-5687

Broad Mountain Wind Balloon Test Reset for July 26

Four representative balloons set to rise Friday morning, weather permitting

WEATHERLY, Carbon County (July 25, 2019) — The Broad Mountain Wind Project has rescheduled its balloon test for Friday morning, July 26. Depending on the weather and winds, the balloons are set to rise in the morning and be up sometime between the hours of 9 a.m. and 11 a.m.

Four balloons will be elevated within the footprint of the proposed 21-turbine wind farm in Packer Township to serve as a representative example and provide additional data for site analyses to be submitted as part of the ongoing zoning hearing process. The four balloons will be spread across different parts of the wind farm, with one each on the far eastern and western ends and two others in between along the ridge.

The balloons, about 12 feet in diameter, will be tied to a cable and rise to the height of the proposed 656-foot (200-meter) tall turbines when the blade tip is at its apex. A smaller balloon or bright marker on the same cable will mark the 418-foot (127.5-meter) height of the nacelle, or hub, which sits atop the turbine tower and holds the rotor and blade assemblies.

The team from Digital Design & Imaging Service Inc., which is conducting the test, will monitor height and capture photos from communities to the north and south of the project site for about two hours until roughly 11 a.m., after which the balloons are winched in and deflated before morning winds or other unsafe conditions prevail. More information about the company and its operations is available at www.AirPhotosLIVE.com.

All of these times are weather dependent.

Broad Mountain Wind is providing alerts about the balloon test for residents through several different channels. Among them:

Broad Mountain Wind has a field office in Weatherly Plaza at 202 Carbon Street in Weatherly. More information is available toll-free at 1-866-591-5005.

###

Balloon Test Planned for Broad Mountain this Weekend POSTPONED Because of Changing Weather Conditions

Weatherly Plaza • 202 Carbon Street • Weatherly, PA 18255

Phone Toll Free: 1-866-591-5005

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Media Contact: Kurt Knaus, 717-571-5687

Balloon Test Planned for Broad Mountain this Weekend POSTPONED Because of Changing Weather Conditions

New dates will be scheduled and announced

WEATHERLY, Carbon County (July 18, 2019) — The balloon test planned for this weekend on Broad Mountain has been POSTPONED due to high winds and unsafe weather.

Four balloons were scheduled to rise within the footprint of the proposed 21-turbine wind farm in Packer Township to serve as a representative example of the project and provide additional data for site analyses to be submitted as part of the ongoing zoning hearing process.

The test was set to run Saturday, July 20, weather permitting, with backup dates on Sunday and Monday. However, high winds and unsafe conditions related to changing weather patterns forced the delay.

New test dates will be determined and announced soon.

The tests are being planned and conducted by Digital Design & Imaging Service Inc. More information about the company and its operations is available at www.AirPhotosLIVE.com.

Broad Mountain Wind will provide alerts about the balloon test for residents through several different channels. Among them:

Broad Mountain Wind has a field office in Weatherly Plaza at 202 Carbon Street in Weatherly. More information is available toll-free at 1-866-591-5005.

###

Standard-Speaker: Windmill hearing continues today

By JIM DINO / Published: July 16, 2019

The ninth evening of a zoning hearing into a proposal to build almost two dozen, 50-story windmills atop Broad Mountain in Packer Twp. will be today at 6 p.m. at Weatherly Area High School.

Attorney Brian P. Stahl, representing Algonquin/Liberty Power, doing business as Broad Mountain Power, said the firm will present 10 expert witnesses during the zoning hearing.

Stahl was one of a half-dozen attorneys representing Algonquin/Liberty who questioned witnesses at the hearings. Attorney Bruce Anders, representing 194 opponents of the project, also questioned the witnesses.

To date, eight of 10 experts have testified:

■ Dennis Jimeno, a senior engineer for Comsearch, testified while the windmills will not affect cellphone reception, radio broadcasting, or cable or satellite TV reception, he said after analyzing over 200 television stations, the reception of 23 stations will be affected to homes and businesses within a 10-kilometer, or 6.2-mile radius of the windmills. The list includes the Wilkes-Barre/Scranton stations, as well as stations in eastern Pennsylvania — Allentown, Harrisburg, Lancaster/York and Philadelphia.

■ Benjamin M. Doyle, president of Capitol Air Space Group, an expert on aviation, testified one of two private airports owned by Jan Grover will be affected by the windmills, but the other, owned by Ken Sency, will not.

■ Ryan Pohle of Shoner Environmental, the company’s GIS manager and environmental scientist, testified about where the windmills would be placed. Pohle said 21 turbines would be located across the mountain ridge. while five smaller ones may also be constructed. He said they could be seen from 15,000 feet away, or about three miles.

■ William Schneider, director of engineering for Shoener Environmental, testified there are no anticipated negative impacts to surface water or groundwater features related to this project.

■ Michael Hankard, of Hankard Enviromental, Verona, Wisconsin, an expert on sound and noise, testified he used topographical data and a computer model to determine the level of noise the wind turbines would produce. The Packer Twp. ordinance limits the noise level to 50 decibels at the property line, and the loudest level the model showed was 48 decibels, Hankard said.

■ Dr. Jim Salmon, President, Zephyr North in Burlington, Ontario, testified that during icing events, which should only occur on an average of only seven days per year, that the turbines’ icing detection system should put the turbines into an ice alarm state, shut them down and put them into a standstill position.

Salmon also testified about shadow flicker, which refers to the moving shadows that an operating wind turbine may cast at certain times of the day when the turbine rotor is between the sun and a receptor’s position.

He testified there are no human health impacts caused by shadow flicker from wind turbines, and in particular by the proposed Broad Mountain wind farm.

■ Jack Coyle, President, Coyle, Lynch & Co., said he had studied what happened to property values after the construction of wind farms in two areas with similar characteristics as the Packer Twp. and Nesquehoning areas. The study and expert concluded that the siting of a wind turbine farm does not have an adverse impact on the selling prices of residences and vacant land parcels in its vicinity.

■ Ian MacRobbie, vice president, operations, Liberty Resources, testified on how wind turbines operate and how they are maintained, as well as required emergency response plans.

Contact the writer: jdino@standardspeaker.com 570-501-3585

https://www.standardspeaker.com/news/windmill-hearing-continues-today-1.2508636

Broad Mountain Wind to Conduct Balloon Test

Weatherly Plaza • 202 Carbon Street • Weatherly, PA 18255

Phone Toll Free: 1-866-591-5005

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Media Contact: Kurt Knaus, 717-571-5687

Broad Mountain Wind to Conduct Balloon Test

Four representative balloons set to rise Saturday, July 20, weather permitting

WEATHERLY, Carbon County (July 16, 2019) — The Broad Mountain Wind Project will elevate four balloons within the footprint of the proposed 21-turbine wind farm in Packer Township to serve as a representative example and provide additional data for site analyses to be submitted as part of the ongoing zoning hearing process.

The balloons are set to be elevated shortly after sunrise on Saturday, July 20, weather permitting. The six-person team will monitor height and capture photos from communities to the north and south of the project site for about two hours until 8 a.m., after which the balloons are winched in and deflated before morning winds or other unsafe conditions prevail.

If there is fog, the start of the test time will be extended until most of it burns off, and then the ascent will begin accordingly, lasting approximate two hours for the photos.

Broad Mountain is a windy environment, thus the proposal to build a wind farm there. The air must be calm and still for the balloon test to function safely and properly. If the test cannot be performed Saturday morning, efforts will be made again during that same evening, beginning around 5 p.m., assuming weather cooperates and there are no lightening or evening thunderstorms.

If the test cannot be performed Saturday, efforts will be made again during the same times on Sunday, July 21 and Monday, July 22. If weather prevents all of the tests, new dates will be proposed.

The balloons, about 12 feet in diameter, will be tied to a cable and rise to the height of the proposed 656-foot (200-meter) tall turbines when the blade tip is at its apex. A smaller balloon on the same cable will mark the 418-foot (127.5-meter) height of the hub, which sits atop the turbine tower and holds the rotor and blade assemblies.

The four balloons will be spread across different parts of the wind farm, with one each on the far eastern and western ends and two others in between along the ridge. The tests are being conducted by Digital Design & Imaging Service Inc. More information about the company and its operations is available at www.AirPhotosLIVE.com.

Broad Mountain Wind will provide alerts about the balloon test for residents through several different channels. Among them:

Broad Mountain Wind has a field office in Weatherly Plaza at 202 Carbon Street in Weatherly. More information is available toll-free at 1-866-591-5005.

Fox56: Plan in works for 290 acre wind farm in Carbon County

by Fox56 Newsroom — June 13, 2019

CARBON COUNTY (WOLF) — There are new plans in the works for a 290 acre wind farm in Carbon County.

Broad Mountain Power wants to install 21 wind turbines in Packer Township.

Each of them will connect to new substations that transfers electricity to the transmission network.

The project will generate 128 million dollars for Pennsylvania and support 420 jobs every year.

The company presented plans to the zoning board tonight.

“Renewable energy is a very positive thing-it’s good economically, it’s good environmentally, it creates local jobs, and produces clean power. It’s low cost power so the benefits far outweigh any of its impacts,” said Project Manager Rob Miller.

When it’s finished, the project will also produce enough clean electricity to power about 25,000 homes a year.

If approved, construction could begin next Spring.

RELEASE: New Study Outlines Economic Impact of Broad Mountain Wind

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Media Contact: Kurt Knaus, 717-571-5687

Construction to bring $93 million to Carbon Co., creating 270 jobs with $6 million in earnings, with long-term operations generating $2.7 million locally

WEATHERLY, Carbon County (June 11, 2019) — The proposed 80-megawatt Broad Mountain Wind Project will generate $93 million in economic activity in Carbon County during construction while supporting 270 direct, indirect and induced jobs with $6 million in earnings, according to a new study by Econsult Solutions Inc., which evaluates the economic and fiscal outcomes of developments.

Beyond the one-time economic impacts from construction, direct operating expenditures at Broad Mountain upon completion will generate an estimated $3.1 million annually within Pennsylvania, with $2.7 million of that total occurring in Carbon County, the study reports. The wind farm’s operation also will yield increases in state and local tax bases.

“The economic benefits of wind energy are widely known,” said Project Manager Rob Miller. “What this study does is help us quantify more clearly exactly how the host communities and those around the project will benefit. Our goal is to ensure that communities realize the full economic benefits of wind energy, not just in the short term but over the long term as well.”

The Carbon County portion represents the largest portion of economic activity. Overall, the project will generate $128 million for Pennsylvania and support 420 annualized jobs with $16 million in earnings over the construction period because of spillover effects that stimulate business activity and support increased employment across a variety of sectors in the state.

Construction also will generate one-time income, sales and business taxes to Pennsylvania totaling approximately $1.9 million from the direct, indirect and induced economic activity.

There are sustained, lasting benefits beyond construction, according to the study.

Each year, the direct operating expenditures at Broad Mountain will generate an estimated $3.1 million in economic impact within Pennsylvania and support 10 jobs with $1 million in earnings. Of this total impact, $2.7 million will occur in Carbon County.

The increases in economic output and employment associated with the wind farm’s operations also yield increases in state and local tax bases, with $57,000 annually to the state in income, sales and 354 Davis Road, Suite 100, Oakville, ON L6J 2X1 www.algonquinpower.com business taxes. In addition to taxes generated for Pennsylvania, approximately $100,900 in property tax revenues will be paid to local jurisdictions. Each year, $82,100 in property taxes will go to Weatherly School District, $17,760 to Carbon County, and $1,040 to Packer Township.

“This is a clear example of how wind projects like this generate long-term, predictable revenue streams for municipalities and schools through tax revenues,” Miller said. “It shows how environmental protection and economic growth go hand in hand.”

The study also explored the added benefits of a community host agreement where the developer works with the municipality to provide additional compensation related to the location and operation of the wind farm within its borders. Based on the model provided, Packer Township could receive nearly $80,000 per year. In February 2019, Broad Mountain proposed a “Host Community Benefits Agreement” to Packer Township based on the model incorporated in this study. No action has been taken to date.

The Broad Mountain Wind Project features 21 turbines in Packer Township, Carbon County, and related transmission line access in Nesquehoning Borough.

Construction cost is expected to be between $145 million and $165 million, including the purchase of the turbines, construction, development fees, and other associated construction costs. Upon completion, the project will produce enough clean electricity to power about 25,000 homes a year.

The full report is available at www.broadmountainwindproject.com, under “PROJECT SUMMARY” and “INDUSTRY INFORMATION.”

###